Crawling along the world’s river bottoms, the larvae of the caddis fly suffer a perpetual housing crisis. To protect themselves from predators, they gather up sand grains and other sediment and paste them all together with silk, forming a cone that holds their worm-like bodies.
As they mature and elongate, they have to continuously add material to the case—think of it like adding rooms to your home for the rest of your life, or at least until you turn into an adult insect.
If the caddis fly larva somehow loses its case, it’s got to start from scratch, and that’s quite the precarious situation for a defenseless tube of flesh. And now, the microplastic menace is piling onto the caddis fly’s list of tribulations.
Microplastic particles—pieces of plastic under 5 millimeters long—have already corrupted many of Earth’s environments, including the formerly pristine Arctic and deep-sea sediments. In a study published last year, researchers in Germany reported finding microplastic particles in the cases of caddis flies in the wild.
Then, last month, they published the troubling results of lab experiments that found the more microplastic particles a caddis fly larva incorporates into its case, the weaker that structure becomes. That could open up caddis flies to greater predation, sending ripple effects through river ecosystems.
Some examples of caddis fly cases. Image A was collected from the wild, and B was built from sand by a larva in the lab. In image C, the larva has incorporated black PVC particles. And in D, it’s blue PET particles.
Courtesy of Tamara Al NajjarYou may wonder why one insect species matters. But caddis flies are critical actors in these ecosystems, and their struggles could well have consequences.
Caddis fly larvae work an important gig hoovering up aquatic vegetation, keeping a river from getting overgrown. As flying adults, they serve as a critical food source for bats, frogs, and spiders.
This study is also helping open up a new front in microplastic science: Researchers have been massively ramping up their work to understand how ingested microplastic particles might affect the physiology and behavior of animals, but relatively little has been done to determine how those particles might affect the structures that insects like caddis flies, bees, and termites build.The researchers used two kinds of plastic in this new experiment, polyvinyl chloride, which you know as PVC, and polyethylene terephthalate, or PET, a clear plastic used to make plastic bottles. In the lab, they chopped up the plastics into tiny pieces, which they mixed with sand in various concentrations.
Then they let the caddis fly larvae do their thing.The researchers found that the larvae used both kinds of microplastic to build their cases, especially in the early stages of construction. “We think that’s because maybe the plastic is lighter, so it’s not as hard to lift,” says biologist Sonja Ehlers of the German Federal Institute of Hydrology, lead author on the paper in the journal Environmental Science and Pollution Research. “And so the larvae start using those lighter materials instead of just choosing sand grains.”Courtesy of Tamara Al NajjarIndeed, if you take a look at the image above, you can see the far end of the case is nearly all blue plastic.
That was the part the larva built first. As the larva grew bigger, it was able to heft bigger and heavier natural grains, which is why the bits of the case closest to its head are sandier.Courtesy of Tamara Al NajjarNow, take a look at this image of the silk holding the particles together. “In cases where there was plastic, the silk there had more holes, and it was not as firm,” Ehlers says. In addition, “plastic is a softer material than sand, and it’s also lighter.
And so this might be a reason why if there’s more plastic and less sand in the case, then it collapses more easily.” Ehlers and her colleagues quantified this with a device that measures how much force is required to crush each case.That’s not good, for the obvious reason that the caddis fly larva relies on the structural integrity of its case to protect itself from predatory fish. And it’s potentially not good for more subtle reasons: The case helps camouflage the larva on the river bottom.
That may not be a problem if the sediment the case is lying in is also littered with the same microplastics the insect used to build its protective outer layer; it will still blend in. But caddis flies often move around a river ecosystem, so if one ends up in an area less contaminated with microplastics, or even more contaminated with them, its technicolored case could make it stick out.
Increased predation could in turn affect the ecosystem as a whole, if the larvae aren’t able to do their work cleaning up vegetation.Being in such close contact with microplastic could cause physiological problems for the larva, as these materials are known to emit toxins known as leachates. “They also use the case for respiration,” Ehlers says. “They are creating water flow inside the case so the water passes their gills.
And so if there’s plastic incorporated, then of course those leachates could also reach the gills maybe and do some harm.”A more long-term concern, for the caddis fly larvae and any number of other organisms at the base of food chains, is bioaccumulation. A small fish eats a larva, a bigger fish eats the smaller fish, all the way on up, and the concentrations of microplastic and associated toxins accumulate over time.
The bigger predators that people eat, like tuna, may be absorbing those microplastics and the chemicals they leach. We still need much, much more research on how microplastic pollution might be affecting different species, but early indications aren’t rosy. Recent research from scientists in the UK, for instance, has shown that hermit crabs exposed to microplastics have trouble choosing new shells.
In addition to teasing out the physiological effects of microplastics on organisms, scientists are only beginning to explore how species like the caddis fly are interacting behaviorally with the stuff, says University of Toronto Scarborough ecologist Scott MacIvor, who wasn’t involved in this new work but has studied how bees are now incorporating plastics into their nests.
Given how pervasive microplastic pollution has become, the effects could be extensive.“It’s very likely that animals are interacting with plastics—which are having negative, neutral, and even in some cases positive impacts to their individual fitness—more often than we realize,” MacIvor says. “We’re just not studying it.
We kind of look past the goose sitting on its nest that’s full of plastic straws and string and other anthropogenic materials.”The pollution problem is only getting worse: According to the consultancy McKinsey, plastic waste may grow from 260 million tons per year in 2016 to 460 million tons by 2030.
Even before the pandemic hit, much of what you “recycled” never actually got recycled, and even more is going straight to the landfill now that recycling facilities are shutting down. For a species like the caddis fly, microplastic particles may well be accumulating over time in its environment.
Plastic, after all, is designed to be ultra-tough, so instead of degrading entirely in ecosystems, it just breaks into ever-smaller pieces that get into ever-smaller crannies.The most visible consequences of plastic pollution, like bags in whale stomachs and six-pack rings around birds’ necks, remain a massive problem.
Now researchers are digging ever deeper to show how tiny, omnipresent pieces of plastic are affecting animals on the micro level. Sadly for species like the caddis fly, there may be no escaping.
More Great WIRED Stories27 days in Tokyo Bay: What happened on the Diamond PrincessTo run my best marathon at age 44, I had to outrun my pastWhy farmers are dumping milk, even as people go hungryWhat is fleeceware, and how can you protect yourself?Tips and tools for cutting your hair at home👁 AI uncovers a potential Covid-19 treatment.
Plus: Get the latest AI news🏃🏽♀️ Want the best tools to get healthy? Check out our Gear team’s picks for the best fitness trackers, running gear (including shoes and socks), and best headphones